Alte replici date lui Dan Alexe - partea I

http://cabalinkabul.wordpress.com/2013/03/19/dacopatii-si-au-gasit-un-profet-deranjat-mintal-dat-afara-din-biserica-pentru-pedofilie/

bogdan bobolea permalink

Erori de logica

• Apelul la emoție: se manipuleze emoțiile celor din audiență, în loc să se folosească raționamente valide.
• Apelul la ridicol: este un specific apel la emoție în care se ridiculizează opinia oponentului
• Ad hominem: atacul la persoana mai degraba decât la argument.

1. bogdan bobolea permalink

   Eu ma refeream la erorile pe care le-ati facut in scrierea articolului dumneavoastra !

   Nu ati argumentat cu nimic ca persoana in cauza nu are competente lingvistice. Ati atacat doar persoana lui.

   Ce am reusit sa aflu este ca are urmatoarele titluri academice

   Dr. = Doctor
   D. D. = Divinitatis Doctor (Doctor of Divinity)
   LL. D. (h. c.) = Doctor of Laws honor causa
   L. Ph. = ?
   L. D. = ?

   Bazandu-ma pe titlurile sale academice si pe faptul ca a provocat “haos” in sala citind un text in limba latina (pentru a-i pune in dificultate pe colegii sai care ar fi trebuit sa stie la perfectie limba latina, si nu cum incercati dvs. sa sugerati ca el ar fi vrut sa distruga ceva) as putea sa inferez ca

   - a studiat limba latina multi ani ?
   - a studiat istoria si evolutia limbii latine ?

   Micheál Ledwith (whose first name is often reported as Michael) was a Catholic priest of the Diocese of Ferns in County Wexford from 1967 to 2005. After a promising academic start he was promoted rapidly and served for a time as Dean of St Peter’s Diocescan College in Wexford. In 1977 he was appointed to a senior lectureship in Dogmatic Theology at St Patrick’s College, Maynooth under the College President, Dr Tomás Ó Fiaich. He remained at Maynooth for the next 16 years and advanced quickly up the ladder of offices, serving a term as Dean of the Faculty of Theology, before being appointed to the Chair of Systematic Theology and later a College Vice-President. In 1985 Dr Ó Fiaich, by then Cardinal Archbishop of Armagh and one of the trustees of Maynooth, approved his appointment to the post of President of Maynooth,[1] which office carried an ex officio Pro-Vice Chancellorship of the National University of Ireland and membership of the Conference of the Heads of Irish Universities.

   The Presidency of Maynooth, at that time, was a senior position within the Catholic Church and considered the gateway to glowing career. Ledwith, appointed at 44, proved a capable administrator at Maynooth and was seen as a rising star; immediately prior to his resignation he presided over the separation of the National University of Ireland, Maynooth and the Pontifical College.[2] Intelligent, urbane and charming he was regarded within the church as a progressive and it was expected that he would soon be appointed to a prominent Bishopric. In 1988 the See of Dublin became vacant following the sudden death of Archbishop Kevin McNamara, and Ledwith was mentioned in the press as a likely successor. His name was submitted to Rome as one of three possible candidates.[3] There was considerable surprise following the appointment of a relatively low-profile University College Dublin academic, Professor Desmond Connell.[4]

   Ledwith was then appointed a Domestic Prelate with the title of Monsignor, and

   served for 17 years under Pope John Paul as a member of the International Theological Commission,

   a small group of theologians of international standing charged with advising the Holy See on theological matters. He also served as Chairman of the Conference of the Heads of Irish Universities and as a member of the Governing Bureau of the Conference of European University Rectors (CRE).

   - daca a avut o asemenea cariera profesionala este posibil sa fii avut acces la multe surse de informatii ?

   Cu alte cuvinte: este oare posibil ca o persoana sa poata avea o opinie avizata cu privire la un anumit domeniu, bazandu-se pe niste surse credibile si acceptabile, CHIAR DACA NU ARE pregatire in acel domeniu ?

   Reply
2. 
   bogdan bobolea permalink

   Am uitat sa mentionez faptul ca utilizati tehnica asocierii persoanei atacate (in cazul nostru Miceal Ledwith) cu persoane care au o notorietate scazuta (in cazul nostru : Bivolaru).